Skip to main content

US Supreme Court conservatives revive criticism of gay marriage ruling


Two conservative justices mounted a fresh attack on Monday on the landmark 2015 ruling that legalized gay marriage nationwide even as the US Supreme Court rebuffed a bid by a former Kentucky official to avoid lawsuits over her refusal to grant marriage licenses to two same-sex couples.

The court turned away an appeal by Kim Davis, who had served as Rowan County clerk, of a lower court ruling that let the lawsuits accusing her of violating the constitutional rights of the couples proceed.

In an opinion accompanying that action, Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, wrote that the same-sex marriage ruling, known as Obergefell v. Hodges, continues to have "ruinous consequences" for religious liberty. Thomas and Alito both dissented in the Obergefell ruling.

"Davis may have been one of the first victims of this court`s cavalier treatment of religion in its Obergefell decision, but she will not be the last," Thomas wrote.

Thomas and Alito agreed on technical grounds with the decision to reject the Davis appeal. But Thomas took the opportunity to assert that the Obergefell decision has left "those with religious objections in the lurch" and made it easier to label them bigots "merely for refusing to alter their religious beliefs in the wake of prevailing orthodoxy."

The court "has created a problem that only it can fix," Thomas added.

LBGT advocacy groups took those comments as an ominous sign for same-sex marriage and gay rights on a court moving further rightward.

"These comments made clear that the war on marriage equality, against the lives of same-sex couples, is alive and well," said Alphonso David, president of the Human Rights Campaign LGBT advocacy group.

If the Senate confirms President Donald Trump`s nominee Amy Coney Barrett, a favorite of Christian conservatives, the court would have a 6-3 conservative majority. With Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg`s death and Justice Anthony Kennedy`s retirement, only three of the justices who comprised the court`s 5-4 majority in the Obergefell ruling still serve on the bench.

Jim Obergefell, a lead plaintiff in the 2015 case, said the opinion by Thomas and Alito signaled that the justices are willing to overturn the right to same-sex marriage.

"It is unthinkable that Alito, Thomas and others on the Supreme Court would want to take away that right and the dignity that comes along with it," Obergefell said.

The Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last year that Davis could be sued in her individual capacity as the former county clerk. It rejected her argument that she is protected by a legal doctrine called qualified immunity, which can shield government officials from liability in certain cases.

Davis was jailed for five days for defying court orders in the aftermath of the Obergefell decision to issue licenses to same-sex couples.

The couples - David Ermold and David Moore, and Will Smith and James Yates - sued Davis in 2015, accusing her of violating their constitutional right to marry as recognized in the Obergefell ruling. Both couples received licenses while Davis was jailed.

In the ruling, the court found that the Constitution`s guarantees of due process and equal protection under the law meant states cannot ban same-sex marriages.

A number of cases have arisen around the country testing the Obergefell decision`s scope and the rights of people to object to gay marriage on religious grounds.

On November 4, the justices are due to hear a religious rights case involving Philadelphia`s refusal to place children for foster care with a Catholic agency that bars same-sex couples from serving as foster parents.


Popular posts from this blog

France suffers worst day since outbreak with 833 coronavirus deaths in 24 hours

A medical worker administers a test for a COVID-19 at a facility in Camden, N.J., Wednesday, April 1, 2020.The new coronavirus causes mild or moderate symptoms for most people, but for some, especially older adults and people with existing health problems, it can cause more severe illness or death.(Matt Rourke/AP)

The coronavirus pandemic killed 833 French people in just 24 hours, making it the nation’s deadliest day since the global outbreak started in China and quickly spread to the rest of the world. Health Minister Olivier Véran warned Monday that despite the tragic figure, France has still not yet seen the worst of the virus, BBC News reported. “We have not reached the end of the ascent of this epidemic,” he said. “We must keep up our efforts as citizens by staying at home." The total number of cases, combining hospital and nursing home statistics, increased by 5,171 between Sunday and Monday to 98,010.
By early Tuesday, the number of infected climbed to 98,984, meaning France wi…

Citing lack of masks and soap, Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez fears Brooklyn federal jail is ‘powder keg of coronavirus infection’

Rep. Nydia Velazquez(Jacquelyn Martin/AP)

Measures to combat a COVID-19 outbreak inside a federal jail in Brooklyn are woefully inadequate, Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez wrote in a letter Monday, detailing screwups she fears will make the lockup “a potential powder keg of coronavirus infection.” Soap is in short supply at the Metropolitan Detention Center on the Sunset Park waterfront, according to the letter Velazquez sent to the Bureau of Prisons Monday. Yet correctional officers and other staff are prohibited from bringing alcohol-based hand sanitizer or their own face masks to work. Staff are rotated in and out of four housing units in quarantine without adequate protective gear, Velazquez wrote. Correctional officers who go home with COVID-19 symptoms are routinely ordered to return to work “in a couple days,” according to the letter. Meanwhile, the jail holding 1,700 inmates is one of the busiest in the federal system, with 150 or 200 inmates coming or going from the facility per we…

Chris Cuomo’s wife Cristina updates husband’s condition in battle against coronavirus

Cristina and Chris Cuomo attend the Opening Of John Varvatos Madison Avenue on April 3, 2014 in New York City. Cristina gave a detailed Instagram update Monday on her husband's condition and treatment as he battles coronavirus.(Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images for John Varvatos)

CNN anchor Chris Cuomo is making progress in his battle against coronavirus after a brutal week that included shivering so violently that he chipped a tooth. The newsman, brother of Gov. Cuomo, was on “day 11” Monday, marking the time since he first exhibited allergy-like symptoms, his wife, Cristina Cuomo, posted in an update on Instagram. “Many have asked how Chris is doing and what meds he’s taking. Here’s an update,” she said in a post that began with, “Every day is a gift.” “After one week of up and down symptoms — chills, body aches, total exhaustion, sleeplessness, and a fever that hit 103, he is on day 11 today, (day 1 being first day of allergy-like symptoms) — he seems slightly better, but still feels the…